John Muir Story – Misleading Good News?

Cctjohnmuir11282006 Page 3 of today’s Contra Costa Times has this headline:

John Muir expansion gains approval

As a member of the Concord Planning Commission that has yet to formally consider the project that caught my attention. (The online version uses a different but still misleading headline.)

"Although there are still a few lingering details to work out, John Muir Medical Center officials have approved a long-awaited expansion at the Concord campus that will cost $50 million less than expected."

What?  "…a few lingering details…"  Nothings been approved.  The John Muir Board has decided to move forward with the project and seek city approval.  Cost $50 million less than expected?  Let’s see…what’s that second paragraph say?

"Last month, hospital officials said plans to expand the Grant Street facility had become too expensive, having skyrocketed to $200 million from $100 million just two years earlier, because of rising construction costs. Plans approved unanimously by the John Muir board of directors last week came in around $149 million."

Is it just me or doesn’t that say that the project is now $49 million more than expected?  Or does it depend on when you’re doing the expecting?  Two years ago or last month.

Probably good news for Concord  – just a strange way to write it up.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.